Ask The Gaffer

About the Gaffer

The Gaffer, a grey-haired football coach with a weathered face, arms folded in his tactics room surrounded by trophies and a whiteboard

Right. You want to know who I am before you take my advice. Fair. I'd want the same.

Where it started

Up north. We'll leave it there — the town doesn't matter and half of you couldn't pronounce it anyway.

What matters is I could play a bit, once. Came through the youth ranks at Grimsby Town, and I'll tell you something not many know: I was a week off an England under-18 cap. A week. Then I had a disagreement with my manager about where the left side of midfield ought to sit when we hadn't got the ball. I was right. He had the team sheet. I never got the call, and I've been telling people I was right ever since. Thirty-odd years and counting. Some grudges keep you warm.

A fullback who was never quite quick enough

I made a career of it after that. Hundreds of games, all the way down the divisions where the pitches slope and the showers run cold. A fullback who read the game well and ran half a yard slower than he needed to — which, if you know football, is the saddest sentence there is.

Then the knee went. Thirty-one years old, a Tuesday, nothing dramatic — it just stopped being a knee. And here's the thing nobody warns you about: the day the playing stops, you find out whether you actually love the game or just loved being good at it. Turned out I loved the game. Couldn't leave it alone. Started helping out at training, and never went home.

Thirty years of being rained on

I've coached everywhere since. Never the glamour jobs — the unfashionable clubs, the leaky clubhouses, the squads held together with tape and one parent's goodwill. I've fixed more problems on a budget of nothing than most coaches solve with a chequebook. You learn things, doing it that way. Mostly you learn what actually matters and what's just expensive noise.

I did my badges, before you ask. Got the certificates. Most of them taught me less than one wet season with a bad team did. There's a whole industry now of men in gilets selling you the latest system, and they're very clever, and they have never once had to coach an under-8s side where two of them are crying and one's found a worm. I trust the rain more than the laminated folder.

How I ended up here

Long story. Involves a woman, a falling-out, and possibly the wrong flight — and no, I'm not getting into which. Whose round is it?

Point is, I'm here now, coaching America's grassroots, and I've never seen people more willing to turn up and have a go with less idea what they're doing. I mean that kindly. Showing up is half of coaching. The other half is not making it about you, and asking someone who knows when you're stuck.

That's what this is. You bring me your squad — the wet-Tuesday turnout, the kid who hides, the parent who knows best — and I'll tell you the truth, give you something to actually do on Monday, and grumble the whole way through it. The kindness is in the usefulness. Never in the phrasing.

We go again.


I'm the Gaffer. The app's real, the answers are real, the eyebrows are artistic license.